Hello! I’ve just started the Critter Love complete and salads. Was wondering if Critter Love Complete should be so watery?

Yes, it's watery. It will freeze as hard as an ice cube. Many use ice cube trays to freeze and store it. I use 2 oz cups with lids and thaw them before their dinner time.

I use the rubber ice trays with lids as they are easy to push out the cube by running a little warm water over the bottom of the tray. I freeze the liquid then dump the cubes into a freezer baggie. I make four weeks at a time and love the ease of feeding this provides!